VPN test: A comparison of the top 5 VPN providers

VPN test: A comparison of the top 5 VPN providers

Stefan Petri
published:

Are you looking for the perfect VPN that not only protects your data, but is also super-fast and connects you worldwide? I hear you! There are a plethora of options out there, and the choice can be overwhelming. But don't worry, I've done the legwork for you. In this article, I'll introduce you to the five best VPN providers that I've put through their paces. Whether you want to bypass geo-restrictions, protect your online privacy or simply surf securely in a café, you'll find the right provider for your needs here. Let's find out together which VPN wins the race! For NordVPN in particular, I will explain the registration/purchase & installation in detail. It will be similar for all other providers and I will refrain from providing detailed instructions because otherwise it would bloat the article too much.

b_390,b_406,b_405,b_295

Table of contents

Why you should consider using a VPN

In our increasingly digitalized world, where privacy and online security have become key issues, VPNs (Virtual Private Networks) are becoming more and more important. A VPN is not just a tool for the tech-savvy or privacy enthusiasts, but offers practical solutions for everyday online activities. Here are some reasons why using a VPN could be useful for you.

1. protection on public Wi-Fi networks: Public Wi-Fi networks are convenient, but they're also a playground for cybercriminals. If you go online without protection in a café, airport or hotel, someone could intercept your data. A VPN encrypts your internet connection, so your information is safe even if you're on an unsecure network.

2. privacy: Your internet service provider (ISP) can see everything you do online, and in some cases this data is stored or even sold to third parties. A VPN hides your internet activity from your ISP by routing your data through an encrypted tunnel, giving you more privacy.

3. bypassing geo-restrictions: Some content on the internet is geographically restricted due to copyright or licensing agreements. With a VPN, you can change your IP address to pretend you're in a different country, giving you access to a world of content that would otherwise be blocked.

4. secure remote access: Especially in times when working from home has become the norm, a VPN enables secure remote access to your company's networks and resources. This is crucial to preserve the integrity of sensitive information.

5. avoid bandwidth throttling: Some ISPs intentionally throttle your internet speed based on your activity or overall usage at peak times. Since a VPN hides your online activity, it can help avoid this type of throttling.

6. improve online gaming: For gamers, a VPN can reduce latency, allow access to games that are not available in certain regions, and provide additional protection against DDoS attacks.

7. online shopping and banking: A VPN provides an extra layer of security when conducting financial transactions online, especially when doing so on the go.

Despite these benefits, it's important to understand that a VPN doesn't solve all online security problems. It is an important tool in your security toolkit, but it should be used in conjunction with other practices such as using strong passwords, regularly updating your software and having a basic understanding of online security principles.

Ultimately, a VPN provides a significant layer of protection for your online activity. Whether it's protecting your data, maintaining your online privacy or simply enjoying free access to the internet, the benefits of a VPN cannot be overstated. In a world where online threats are becoming increasingly sophisticated, a VPN can be an indispensable tool for anyone who values their digital security and freedom.

Test winner: NordVPN*

VPN test: A comparison of the top 5 VPN providers - NordVPN

Let's take an in-depth look at NordVPN* , the provider that came out on top in our test. NordVPN has made a name for itself thanks to its impressive combination of speed, security and ease of use. Here are the key features that made NordVPN the test winner:

1. security and privacy: NordVPN takes security very seriously. With strong 256-bit encryption, a strict no-logs policy and the use of Double VPN, where your data is rerouted through two separate servers, NordVPN sets the standard for security. This means that your online activities and personal data are protected from even the most prying eyes.

2. speed: Many VPNs slow down your internet connection, but NordVPN manages to maintain high speeds. With thousands of servers in over 60 countries, you'll always find a fast and reliable server near you or in the country whose content you want to access. In my DSL speed test, I was able to achieve almost the same values as when surfing normally without a VPN. BUT: When I call up a new website, it is sometimes slightly slower than normal because the click first has to be sent to the VPN server, e.g. in America, and only from there to the target server. So don't be surprised.

3. user-friendliness: The NordVPN apps for Windows, macOS, iOS, Android and even Linux are intuitive and easy to use. Even if you're a VPN newbie, you'll have no trouble setting up and launching NordVPN. Just a few clicks and you're connected to one of the many servers worldwide.

4. streaming and torrenting: NordVPN is an excellent choice for streaming fans. It works seamlessly with platforms like Netflix, Hulu, BBC iPlayer, and others, so you can enjoy your favorite shows and movies no matter where you are. NordVPN also offers dedicated P2P servers for fast and secure torrenting.

5. customer support: If you have any questions or problems, NordVPN customer support is available around the clock via live chat and email. The support is competent and friendly, which is especially helpful if you need quick answers.

6. additional functions: NordVPN offers some extra features that really stand out, such as CyberSec, which provides extra protection against ads and malware, and the ability to get a dedicated IP address.

All in all, NordVPN offers a top-notch combination of security, speed and ease of use, making it an excellent choice for anyone looking for a reliable VPN service. Whether you're a security conscious, a streaming enthusiast or simply someone who values their online privacy, NordVPN has something for everyone. The only downside is that there is no free trial. We can only speculate as to why this is the case with most providers. Perhaps because some people only need a VPN provider for a one-off action. But most people fail to realize that protecting their own data should not be a one-off action, but a permanent one.

NordVPN expanded its offering by 50 new virtual locations in March 2024 to meet the growing needs of its users. This strategic decision enables access to regions where it is difficult to set up physical servers. Virtual servers offer the same quality and speed as their physical counterparts. One example is the successful virtual server in India with a physical server in Singapore. This innovation allows NordVPN to offer even broader global coverage without having to be physically present in every country. Users will soon be able to take advantage of these new locations via the latest app updates, catapulting NordVPN to the forefront of VPN services.

It's impressive to read that NordVPN operates more than 6000 servers in 111 locations. Also very cool: One license, 10 devices!
NordVPN has expanded its offering and now allows users to protect up to 10 devices simultaneously with one account. Previously, users could secure up to six devices, but due to the increasing number of internet-connected devices, NordVPN has increased the number of simultaneous connections. This move allows you to secure more of your devices at the same time without having to choose between them, increasing your online privacy and security.

Pricing and plans: NordVPN offers different subscription plans that are good value for money for most users. The monthly subscription costs 11.95 euros, while the two-year subscription is significantly cheaper at 3.09 euros per month. All plans include use on up to 10 devices simultaneously. However, there are also other prices, depending on how many features you need.

To summarize, NordVPN is one of the best VPN providers on the market. With its outstanding security, performance and user-friendliness, the service is an excellent choice for anyone who wants to reliably protect their online activities. Click here to go to NordVPN*.

The ordering process

Let's go through the entire ordering process. When you're on the NordVPN website, you can choose from various packages. Of course, you'll save the most if you sign up for 2 years right away. The 30-day money-back guarantee is also worth mentioning here. I choose the Plus package, which is probably the most popular.

VPN test - the top 5: NordVPN

The next step is payment. Commendable: I can even pay with crypto. I've never seen that before.

VPN test: A comparison of the top 5 VPN providers - NordVPN order

I used my favorite payment method PayPal and then I got to this screen (before I got an error page, but I could just click it away or go back one step from the URL and then everything was okay):

VPN test: A comparison of the top 5 VPN providers - NordVPN order completed

Now I click on "Connect to VPN" so that I can download the app. I get to this screen and click on "Download app" and after the download I run the setup file:

VPN test: A comparison of the top 5 VPN providers - NordVPN Setup

After the installation, I clicked on Sign in and then I was finally done.

VPN test: A comparison of the top 5 VPN providers - NordVPN installation completed

Once everything was done, I was finally able to start the actual program:

VPN test: A comparison of the top 5 VPN providers - NordVPN program interface

The program interface is really nice and tidy and I selected America straight away so that I could use the Claude.ai app. Because that hadn't worked with my VPN service from Google. Lo and behold, I can actually use Clauda.ai, even though it hasn't yet been activated in Germany as of April 2024:

Claude AI via VPN

On the negative side, the AdBlock is not really better than the AdBlock extension (but I guess all AdBlock providers struggle with this, that they are recognized too quickly):

VPN test: A comparison of the top 5 VPN providers - NordVPN AdBlock

I also don't like the fact that I have absolutely no way of downloading a trial version. But well, that's what the 30-day money-back guarantee is for.

All in all, I can really recommend the program because it's fast and easy to use, has lots of features and I even have the option of subscribing to it on a monthly basis.

Click here to go to NordVPN*.


SurfShark*

Surfshark VPN

Surfshark has quickly made a name for itself in the world of VPN services and offers a range of features that set it apart from other providers. Here's a comprehensive review of Surfshark, covering key aspects such as security, speed, server selection, ease of use, pricing and customer support.

Security and privacy:
Surfshark takes the security of its users very seriously. With robust AES 256-bit encryption, a strict no-logs policy and a secure kill switch, Surfshark ensures that your data remains protected. Additionally, it offers features like MultiHop, where you can route your connection across multiple countries at once to cover your tracks on the web even better.

Speed:
When it comes to speed, Surfshark is hardly inferior to other top VPN providers. Of course, there is always some loss of speed when using a VPN, but Surfshark continuously optimizes its servers to keep this loss to a minimum. Speeds may vary depending on the server you choose, but in general Surfshark offers fast connection speeds that are well-suited for streaming, gaming and other data-intensive activities.

Server selection and locations:
Surfshark offers an impressive selection of servers worldwide, allowing you to effectively bypass geographic restrictions and gain access to content from different countries. The variety of server locations is particularly useful for users who value broad geographic coverage.

Ease of use:
Surfshark's user interface is clear and intuitive, making it particularly appealing to VPN newcomers. Apps for different platforms are easy to install and use. Surfshark supports an unlimited number of devices simultaneously, making it an excellent choice for families or users with many devices.

Pricing:
Surfshark is known for its excellent value for money. It offers various subscription plans, all of which are quite affordable, especially if you opt for a long-term subscription. Compared to other premium VPN services, Surfshark is often one of the more cost-effective options without compromising on quality.

Customer support:
Surfshark's customer support is available 24/7 via live chat, which ensures quick and effective help with any problems or questions. Additionally, there is an extensive knowledge base and guides on their website that cover many common questions and troubleshooting issues.

Conclusion:
Surfshark is a strong contender in the VPN market, offering an impressive combination of security, speed and ease of use, all at a very competitive price. It's suitable for both VPN newbies and experienced users looking for a reliable service that offers a wide range of features. Whether you want to stream content, browse the web securely or bypass geo-restrictions, Surfshark is definitely worth considering.

Although Surfshark offers impressive performance, NordVPN is considered superior in some areas. For example, NordVPN has an even more extensive server selection, potentially offering better speeds and a more reliable connection in more regions worldwide. NordVPN has also made a name for itself in terms of security features, such as the Double VPN, which provides additional layers of encryption. In addition, NordVPN has a longer track record and an established reputation in the VPN community, which resonates well with users who value trustworthiness and proven reliability. Although Surfshark offers many advantages, NordVPN is often preferred for its proven performance, wider server selection and additional security features.

Click here to visit SurfShark*.


Proton VPN Plus

VPN test: A comparison of the top 5 VPN providers - Proton VPN

Proton VPN Plus is an enhanced version of the popular VPN service Proton VPN. It offers additional functions and features compared to the free basic service.

What is Proton VPN Plus? Proton VPN Plus is an advanced version of Proton VPN that offers additional security and privacy features. It is a premium service that goes beyond the basic offering and is designed for users who are looking for a more intensive and versatile online security solution. This version is aimed at users who value advanced protection for their online activities.

Features of Proton VPN Plus

Secure core servers: Proton VPN Plus routes your internet traffic through multiple servers before it leaves the network. This increases security and makes it difficult for third parties to determine your true location or identity. It is an additional layer of security that can be particularly beneficial in high-risk environments.

Network protection: This function provides additional protection for your network. If your VPN connection drops unexpectedly, the automatic kill switch function blocks all internet traffic until the secure connection is re-established. This protects your data from unintentional leaks.

High speeds and streaming support: Proton VPN Plus offers improved speeds, which is especially useful when using streaming services or downloading large files. Additionally, Proton VPN Plus allows you to access geo-restricted content and enjoy it in high quality.

These features make Proton VPN Plus a solid choice for anyone with a strong need for online privacy and security.

Proton VPN Plus is aimed at users who require increased security, performance and functionality. It offers comprehensive VPN protection with enhanced features compared to the standard offering.

Proton VPN in action

Prices are similar to NordVPN. It starts at €9.99 per month, although you can save a lot more if you sign up for 2 years. Or you can pay nothing at all if you use the free version (but only on one device and only a maximum of 5 countries to choose from) .

Proton VPN is indeed a strong offering in the VPN market, with a solid security architecture and a respectable privacy policy, making it an attractive choice for many users. The security at Proton VPN is top-notch, especially because it comes from the makers of ProtonMail, an email service known for its security. The company places great emphasis on privacy and transparency, which is not a given in this industry.

However, when we compare Proton VPN with NordVPN, there are a few areas where NordVPN comes out on top. For example, NordVPN offers a larger server selection in more countries. This can be crucial if you're looking for specific geographic coverage or if you want to achieve optimal speeds, as more servers usually means better load balancing and therefore faster speeds.

What's more, NordVPN offers some additional features that Proton VPN might lack. For example, NordVPN offers Double VPN, a feature where your internet connection is routed through two different VPN servers, further increasing security and anonymity. NordVPN's CyberSec feature, which acts as an ad blocker and malware protection, is also a nice extra that not every VPN service offers.

Despite these differences, it's important to emphasize that the choice of VPN service often depends on the user's specific needs and preferences. For example, if your top priority is privacy and you're a fan of open source, Proton VPN, with its strong focus on security and transparency, may well be more appealing. However, NordVPN might be a better choice if you're looking for a wider range of features and server selection. Both services offer excellent quality, but the subtleties in their offerings appeal to different user preferences.

Click here for Proton VPN.


Mullvad VPN

mullvad vpn

Mullvad VPN is a VPN service that places great emphasis on anonymity and privacy for its users. With a simple pricing structure and a strong focus on security, Mullvad stands out from many other VPN providers. In this review, we examine Mullvad VPN's performance, security features, ease of use, customer support and pricing.

Performance and speed: Mullvad VPN offers servers in a variety of countries worldwide. Speed tests show that Mullvad generally offers fast and reliable connections, although speeds can vary depending on server location and load. Latency remains low, and streaming high-definition video or playing online games is usually possible without any problems.

Security and data protection: Mullvad places particular emphasis on security and data protection. The service uses strong encryption methods and supports multiple VPN protocols, including OpenVPN and WireGuard. Mullvad keeps no logs of its users' activities, which means that your online activities remain private. In addition, Mullvad allows payment via anonymous methods such as cash or cryptocurrencies.

Ease of use: Setting up Mullvad VPN is straightforward. The application's user interface is clear and easy to navigate, making it accessible even for VPN beginners. Mullvad offers apps for various operating systems, including Windows, macOS, Linux, Android and iOS.

Customer support: Mullvad offers customer support via email and through a comprehensive FAQ page on their website. Although no live chat or phone support is available, response times for email queries are usually quick, and the information provided is helpful and detailed.

Pricing: One of the most outstanding features of Mullvad is its simple pricing structure. There is a single pricing option that offers the same features to all users. This makes the decision easy and transparent for potential customers. The monthly price is competitive and reflects the value that Mullvad offers in terms of privacy and security. It only costs €5 a month, whether you opt for the monthly or annual model. I've never seen anything like it and I personally think it's really fair!

Verdict: Mullvad VPN is an excellent choice for users who value anonymity and security. While the service may not offer the widest choice of countries or the very fastest speeds, it's hard to beat in terms of security features and privacy practices. Its ease of use and transparent pricing make it an attractive option for VPN beginners and experienced users alike. If your priority is maintaining your online privacy, Mullvad VPN is definitely worth considering.

Mullvad VPN is highly regarded for its strong focus on anonymity and privacy, but it does offer some limitations compared to NordVPN. For one, NordVPN has a much more extensive server network, offering better coverage worldwide and often faster speeds. NordVPN also outperforms Mullvad in terms of ease of use, with apps that are optimized for a wider range of devices and operating systems. While Mullvad is known for its simple pricing and not requiring email addresses to sign up, NordVPN offers additional features such as CyberSec to block ads and malware, as well as Double VPN for an extra layer of encryption. Although Mullvad scores in the privacy aficionado niche, many users prefer NordVPN for its more comprehensive features, better connectivity and user-friendly interface.

Click here to visit Mullvad VPN.


ExpressVPN

ExpressVPN

ExpressVPN is one of the most prominent names in the VPN market, known for its speed, security and ease of use. Here is a detailed review of ExpressVPN that includes its key features, benefits and few drawbacks.

Security and privacy:
ExpressVPN offers top-notch security, including AES 256-bit encryption that protects your data. It has a strict no-logs policy, which means your online activity is not recorded. The kill switch, which immediately cuts your internet connection if the VPN connection drops, provides additional protection.

Speed:
One of the main reasons why users choose ExpressVPN is its impressive speed. It is one of the fastest VPNs on the market, making it ideal for streaming, gaming and downloads. Speed may vary depending on location and server, but overall ExpressVPN offers a reliable and fast connection.

Servers and locations:
ExpressVPN has an extensive server selection with locations in 94 countries, making it easy to bypass geo-restrictions and gain global access to content.

Ease of use:
ExpressVPN's apps are intuitive and easy to use for both beginners and experienced users. It is compatible with a wide range of devices and operating systems, including Windows, macOS, Android, iOS, Linux, and even some routers.

Streaming and torrenting:
ExpressVPN is an excellent choice for streaming as it is compatible with most major streaming services such as Netflix, Hulu, BBC iPlayer, and others. It also offers full support for torrenting, with optimized servers and unlimited bandwidth.

Pricing:
If there's one downside, it's ExpressVPN's pricing, which is higher compared to some of its competitors. However, it does offer a 30-day money-back guarantee, which allows users to test the service risk-free. The monthly price starts from €12.95 and naturally gets cheaper the longer you commit (€8.32 for 12 months).

Customer support:
ExpressVPN's customer support is top-notch, with 24/7 live chat support, prompt responses, and a comprehensive knowledge base.

Comparison with NordVPN:
Although ExpressVPN excels in many areas, there are reasons why some users might prefer NordVPN. NordVPN offers similar security features and privacy, but has an even larger server selection with over 5,000 servers in 59 countries. NordVPN also has dedicated servers for additional requirements such as Double VPN for an extra layer of encryption and Onion over VPN for Tor users. In terms of price, NordVPN is often cheaper, making it more attractive for price-conscious users. NordVPN also has its own security feature called CyberSec, which blocks ads and potentially harmful websites.

Overall, ExpressVPN is a strong choice for users who value speed and ease of use. But if you're looking for slightly better value for money and specialized security features, NordVPN might be a better choice.

Click here to go to ExpressVPN.


477, 944, 910, 359, 892, 842

*Contains an affiliate link.

Published on by Stefan Petri
Published on:
From Stefan Petri
Together with his brother Matthias, Stefan Petri runs the popular specialist forum PSD-Tutorials.de and the e-learning platform TutKit.com, which focuses on the training and further education of digital professional skills.
Back to overview